Chocolate Cranberry Eye of Round Roast Recipe for the Holidays

Disclaimer: The reviewer has received the product/service at a reduced price or for free. I am being compensated to participate in #Switch2Swerve challenge through the Bookieboo Influencer Network . I did switch out my regular sweetener for the Swerve Sweetener from November 18, 2013 through December 20, 2013. All opinions are my own and are my honest opinions based on my own experience with the product.

When I want to serve a holiday roast that feels a little different from an ordinary Sunday dinner, I use cranberry balsamic vinegar for tang and my homemade C-Spice seasoning blend for subtle chocolate notes. There are no whole cranberries or chocolate bars in this recipe. It sounds surprising until you taste how those flavors work together. The result is still very much a beef roast, with seasoned cooking juices that make an ordinary eye of round feel special.

The cranberry balsamic vinegar brings tangy fruit notes that complement the beef, while the warm seasoning blend gives the roast its savory character. The chocolate is already included in the spice blend, so you do not need to add a separate chocolate ingredient. That is what gives this roast its unexpected depth without turning the savory sauce into a dessert. If you want a holiday roast that feels special without relying on an expensive cut of beef, this chocolate cranberry eye of round roast recipe is worth a look.

Round Roast Recipe With Swerve Sweetener

I originally made this roast during the #Switch2Swerve challenge, when I substituted Swerve for the sugar in a holiday meal. The menu included this chocolate cranberry eye of round roast, hot and spicy carrots, and bow tie pasta in creamy sage sauce. Both the roast and carrots originally called for sugar, so I tried Swerve in both dishes. The roast was a success, and the small amount of sweetener balanced the cranberry's tartness without making the beef taste sweet.

Thoughts On The Preparation Of This Round Roast Recipe

This is a roast I would make again. I cooked the original version in my Flavor-Wave Turbo Oven, although I would like to try it in my electric skillet another time. I love the way a roast cooked in that skillet leaves flavorful juices for gravy, especially when potatoes and carrots cook alongside it. That is an idea for a future variation, not a change to the tested recipe below.

If you have never used a Flavor-Wave Turbo Oven, it is a countertop convection oven with a clear glass cooking bowl and a lid that circulates heated air around the food. It lets you watch the roast as it cooks without opening a conventional oven, and its removable cooking racks position the meat closer to or farther from the heat. I used the upper rack first to brown the top of this roast, then moved it to the lower rack to finish cooking. The Flavor-Wave is an older appliance, so if you do not have one, use a conventional oven or another suitable roaster and check the beef with a meat thermometer rather than assuming the cooking times will match.

The most useful preparation you can do ahead of time is to mix the seasoning salt and C-Spice. I keep homemade spice blends on hand because it saves time when supper needs to come together. C-Spice is also where the chocolate enters this recipe, so there is no separate chocolate bar or cocoa powder to measure into the roast.

The original version of this holiday dinner used the Flavor-Wave Turbo Oven. The combination of cranberry balsamic vinegar and the chocolate in the C-Spice blend is what makes the roast memorable. Eye of round is a lean cut, so it benefits from careful cooking and thin slicing. Keep an eye on the internal temperature rather than relying on cooking time alone, and let the meat rest before cutting across the grain. That helps make the finished roast easier to serve.

Planning a Holiday Dinner Around This Roast

For a holiday meal, mix your seasonings in advance and set out the rosemary olive oil, cranberry balsamic vinegar, and roast before you begin. Pat the surface of the beef dry with paper towels so the oil and seasonings adhere more evenly. Measure the thyme, garlic powder, gourmet seasoning salt, C-Spice, and sweetener into a small bowl, then mix thoroughly before sprinkling the blend over the meat. I served mine with hot and spicy carrots and bow tie pasta in creamy sage sauce. The cranberry balsamic vinegar gives the beef a tangy fruit note, while the chocolate in C-Spice adds depth to the seasoned juices. This recipe uses cranberry-flavored vinegar, not whole cranberries or a separate cranberry sauce.

If you use a conventional oven instead of the Flavor-Wave, place the beef on a rack in a roasting pan and monitor the internal temperature closely. The oven's cooking time will vary with the thickness of the roast and your equipment, so do not copy the Flavor-Wave timer without checking doneness.

Serving, Slicing and Saving Leftovers

Before cutting, find the direction of the long muscle fibers in the eye of round. After the roast has rested, use a sharp knife to cut thin slices across those fibers rather than parallel to them. Eye of round is lean, so thin slices and a little of the reserved cooking juice make a noticeable difference at the table.

Spoon any collected cooking juices over the sliced beef, or serve them on the side so everyone can add as much as they like. Because eye of round is lean, avoid letting sliced leftovers sit uncovered or dry out during reheating. Refrigerate leftovers promptly in shallow, covered containers and reheat only the portion you plan to serve, with a little cooking liquid to help keep it moist.

Why Chocolate Works in a Savory Beef Roast

The chocolate in this recipe comes from the C-Spice seasoning blend, not from a separate chocolate ingredient. Make that blend first if you do not already have it in the pantry. Measure the amount called for in the recipe card rather than adding extra cocoa or candy to the roast.

Chocolate does not have to make a dish sweet. In a savory roast, its cocoa notes can add an earthy, slightly bitter richness that complements beef and warm spices. Cranberry balsamic vinegar brings a fruity, acidic contrast, while the tiny amount of sweetener softens its edge. Together, those flavors give the cooking juices more complexity without making the beef taste like chocolate candy.

Expect a beef-forward roast with an herbal crust, a little cranberry tang from the balsamic vinegar, and subtle cocoa notes from the C-Spice. Because the recipe uses only a teaspoon of cranberry balsamic vinegar and three-quarters of a teaspoon of C-Spice, neither flavor should dominate a 2 ½-pound roast. If you want a more pronounced cranberry accompaniment, serve a separate cranberry sauce rather than changing the original tested seasoning amounts.

Can You Make This Roast Without Swerve?

Yes. The original recipe uses only ¼ teaspoon of Swerve on a 2 ½-pound roast, so you can omit it for a less sweet result. The cranberry balsamic vinegar may taste a little sharper without it, but the roast will still have its thyme, garlic, rosemary, and C-Spice flavors. If you are unsure, follow the savory version first and offer a sweeter cranberry condiment at the table.

You can also use regular granulated sugar in place of Swerve at a 1-to-1 measurement in this recipe. If the recipe calls for one tablespoon of Swerve, use one tablespoon of sugar. That changes the sugar content of the finished dish, but it does not require you to recalculate the quantity. The original recipe below records how I made it for the sponsored challenge.

Here is the original Flavor-Wave Turbo Oven recipe, with the ingredient amounts and cooking method I used.

Print

For this roast, the sweetener is a small supporting ingredient, not the main flavor. Start with the original ¼ teaspoon if you want to reproduce my sponsored-challenge version, or leave it out if you prefer a more savory roast. Either way, use a meat thermometer to judge doneness rather than relying only on the oven timer.