How to Make Homemade Lime Sherbet with Goat Milk

Making homemade lime sherbet with goat milk is one of the ways I use milk from our goats throughout the year. We freeze some of our goat milk so we can continue using it during the winter, and this frozen dessert is a good example of what that stored milk can become. In the video below, I show how I make lime sherbet in my electric ice cream maker, using goat milk, whipping cream, lime-flavored gelatin dessert mix, sugar and lime juice that we preserved ourselves.

What I particularly like about this ice cream maker is that I don't have to work with ice and rock salt. I prepare the ingredients, let the machine do the churning, then put the finished sherbet in a covered container in the freezer until it firms up enough to serve. The machine takes roughly 40 to 45 minutes for this batch, although the time can vary with the machine and the temperature of the ingredients. Be sure to use the freezer bowl or other preparation required by your particular ice cream maker.

Ingredients for My Goat Milk Lime Sherbet

• 2 cups goat milk
• 2 cups whipping cream
• 1 cup pure cane sugar
• 3 ounces powdered lime Jell-O gelatin dessert mix
• ¾ cup lime juice, including the pulp if you like it

Those are the amounts I used in the video, not a reformulated recipe. The cream is a practical addition because, unlike cow's milk, goat milk can be more difficult to separate into a useful quantity of cream at home. If your household has a dairy cow and its own cream, you may already have that ingredient available. The powdered lime Jell-O gives the sherbet another layer of lime flavor and influences its sweetness and texture. It is not the same ingredient as plain unflavored gelatin, so don't substitute the two without developing a different recipe.

What Makes This Goat Milk Sherbet Different?

This is not a conventional lime sorbet made with water and fruit juice. My version uses two cups of goat milk and two cups of whipping cream, which gives the dessert a richer dairy base, while the lime juice and powdered lime gelatin dessert mix contribute the citrus flavor. The result is closer to a creamy frozen dessert than a light, icy fruit sorbet. I developed this method around ingredients I actually had available, including goat milk we had frozen for use outside the regular milking season.

The sugar also matters. In a frozen dessert, sugar does more than add sweetness; it influences how firmly the mixture freezes and how easily it can be scooped. That is why I recommend trying the original proportions first. Replacing the cane sugar with a different sweetener or reducing it substantially may change the finished texture even if the sweetness seems right before the mixture freezes. Lime juice provides acidity, and the flavored gelatin mix adds its own sugar, flavoring and setting ingredients, so the combination is different from using fresh lime juice alone.

Getting Your Ice Cream Maker Ready

My electric ice cream maker is convenient because I do not need to assemble a bucket of ice and salt around the container. I prepare the machine as its manufacturer directs, turn it on and add the ingredients while the paddle is moving. Some electric machines have a bowl that must be frozen ahead of time, while others have built-in refrigeration. Knowing which type you have is important because a bowl that has not frozen completely may leave the mixture liquid after a full churning cycle.

Before pouring in the goat milk, check the manufacturer's maximum fill level. This recipe begins with nearly six cups of ingredients before the mixture incorporates any air. In the original video, I notice that my machine is getting quite full, so I stop before it overflows. If yours is smaller, divide the mixture and churn it in batches rather than forcing the entire recipe into one bowl. Starting with properly chilled ingredients can also help the freezer bowl stay cold enough to do its job.

Why I Add the Lime Ingredients Gradually

In the video, I turn on the ice cream maker, pour in the goat milk and whipping cream, and add the cane sugar. Then I sprinkle in the powdered lime Jell-O a little at a time instead of dumping the entire package into one spot. The moving paddle helps distribute the powder through the dairy mixture. This matters because powdered ingredients can form stubborn clumps when they hit liquid all at once. Taking a moment to add the powder gradually is much easier than trying to break up those clumps after the mixture begins to thicken.

I shake the container of lime juice before measuring because I want the pulp distributed through the liquid. I use three-quarters of a cup, including the pulp, and pour it into the running machine. If you prefer a completely smooth sherbet, straining the pulp would be a change you could experiment with, but I leave it in the version I demonstrate. Use the juice quantity from the recipe rather than adding extra simply because you enjoy a tart dessert; more juice changes both the flavor and the balance of liquid in the mixture.

From Soft Sherbet to a Scoopable Dessert

After roughly 40 minutes of churning, I turn off the machine and transfer the sherbet to a covered plastic or glass freezer container. At that stage, the mixture may be softer than the firm scoops you would serve at the table. The second freeze is what allows it to set more firmly. I plan for it to finish freezing by evening rather than treating the churning time as the entire time needed to make the dessert.

A broad, freezer-suitable container can help the mixture cool more evenly than a very deep one. Keep it covered to avoid absorbing freezer odors and to protect the surface. When you are ready to serve, scoop only what you need and return the remainder to the freezer. If the sherbet has become very firm, allow a little time for it to soften enough to scoop without forcing a utensil through a rock-hard block.

Planning a Batch for Your Household

My ingredient measurements add up to approximately five and three-quarter cups before churning, plus the small amount of volume contributed by the powdered mix. The final yield depends on your ice cream maker and how much air is incorporated. As a practical starting point, you can plan on about twelve half-cup servings from a batch, but measure the actual finished volume if you want to record a precise yield in your recipe collection. This is a generous batch for a household dessert, especially when you are serving it after a meal.

If you are making sherbet for a gathering, think about freezer space before starting. You will need room to freeze or prepare the machine according to its instructions and then room for the finished container. The active work is fairly short, but the machine and the second freezing stage require a little planning. This is one of those recipes where doing the preparation early in the day can make dessert easier later, when you may also be cooking supper or taking care of livestock.

Using Frozen Goat Milk from the Homestead

One of the things I appreciate about freezing goat milk is being able to use it for recipes long after the milking season changes. If you've frozen milk for winter, thaw the quantity you need in the refrigerator and mix it back together if it has separated. That gives you the measured two cups for this recipe without needing to have fresh milk available the same day you want sherbet.

The whipping cream provides richness that can be difficult to collect in large amounts from goat milk. You may notice that goat milk behaves differently from cow's milk in your own dairy recipes, which is one reason I wanted to show precisely how I made this batch rather than provide a generic sherbet formula.

Tips for Getting the Texture You Want

Start with a properly prepared ice cream maker and ingredients that are chilled according to the manufacturer's instructions. An ice cream maker with a frozen bowl often needs that bowl fully frozen before churning can begin. Pouring a batch this large into an undersized machine could prevent proper freezing, so check the maximum fill line and reduce the recipe if necessary.

Freshly churned sherbet may be soft enough to scoop but not firm enough to hold its shape in a bowl. Moving it into a lidded freezer container helps it finish setting. If the finished sherbet becomes very hard after extended freezer storage, let the serving container soften briefly in the refrigerator before scooping rather than leaving the entire batch on the kitchen counter.

Frequently Asked Questions About Lime Sherbet

Can I use frozen goat milk?

Yes. That is one of the reasons I make this recipe. Thaw your frozen milk in the refrigerator and use the measured amount once it is fully thawed and mixed.

Do I need to skim cream from my goat milk?

No. My video uses purchased whipping cream alongside the goat milk, because collecting that much cream from goat milk can be difficult. It is a practical way to make the recipe without needing a cream separator.

Why is there lime Jell-O in the recipe?

It is part of the recipe I demonstrated. The lime-flavored powdered dessert mix adds lime flavor, sweetness and gelatin to the mixture. Use the specified product or recognize that changing it will produce a different result.

How long should the sherbet churn?

I set my timer for 40 minutes in the video and describe the machine as taking around 45 minutes for frozen desserts. Use the condition of the mixture and your own ice cream maker's instructions to decide when it is ready to transfer to the freezer.

Watch My Lime Sherbet Video

Print

The video below shows me adding each ingredient to the electric ice cream maker, explains why I use whipping cream with goat milk, and demonstrates how I portion the home-preserved lime juice. If you've raised dairy goats, I would love to hear how you use your extra milk in frozen desserts.

Learn how easy it is to make homemade lime sherbet.