Cute Santa Claus Nutter Butter Christmas Cookie Ideas

Cute Santa Claus Nutter Butter Christmas Cookie Ideas tucked into a dish nestled among tissue paper.
Save Recipe

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

No reviews




  1. Melt the Wilton Candy Melts in the microwave for 30 seconds.  Stirring the white chocolate with a wooden skewer.
  2. Stir and if the candy is not melted, return it to the microwave and set it for another 10 seconds. Stir the candy. If it is still not melted, repeat this process until the candy is fully melted. Take care to not overheat the candy.   Dipping the Nutter Butter Sandwich cookie into the melted white chocolate.
  3. Dip one end of the Nutter Butter Cookie into the melted white chocolate.  Sprinkling the white chocolate with red sprinkles to create Santa's hat.
  4. Hold the cookie over a bowl and sprinkle the red sugar candies on the white chocolate making sure to turn the cookie over to coat all of the chocolate.  The Nutter Butter cookies laying on the wire rack.
  5. Hold onto the cookie for a moment to let the icing dry and then lay it on a wire rack.
  6. Continue this process until all the cookies are done.
  7. Place two wooden skewers across the wire rack leaving one opening in between them (see photo).
  8. Dip the other end of the cookie in the white chocolate.
  9. Use a skewer to swirl the chocolate to create the beard.  Wooden skewers on a wire rack holding the cookies above it so the melted chocolate does not touch the metal rack.
  10. Lay the cookie on the wooden skewers in such a way that the white chocolate beard does not touch the skewers or the wire rack.
  11. Continue dipping the cookies and making the beards until all the cookies are complete.
  12. Now begin decorating the cookies. You can use the icing or you can use the white chocolate. I felt the icing worked better, but this is a personal preference.
  13. Place two eyes on the face and attach them either with icing or chocolate.
  14. Do the same thing for the nose, which is the cinnamon red hot candy.
  15. Lastly attach the white chocolate chip to the hat to create a tassel.  The Nutter Butter cookies being decorated.
  16. Now set the cookies aside and let them dry for an hour up to overnight.
  17. Eat and enjoy!
Recipe Card powered byTasty Recipes